And it certainly doesn't depend on an observer to make this happen. Interspersed with Amanda's woes and the pseudoscience are random attacks on organized religion. Present thinking on neurology and addiction are covered in some detail but,. But they add that the film shows quantum mysteries selectively to shore up metaphysical points. Now comes the audio edition of the book based on the mind-boggling movie that grossed $11 million in the U.S. alone. You might think that meant there were 18% fewer violent crimes than in the previous year, but the decrease was actually relative to his predicted increase based on some fancy statistical footwork. A moderately low-budget independent film, it was promoted using viral marketing methods and opened in art-house theaters in the western United States, winning several independent film awards before being picked up by a major distributor and eventually grossing over $10 million. Easton's 1897 Bible Dictionary. It's truly amazing that you can separate two elementary particles that were originally tied together, and often make a measurement of one particle that instantly affects the other, even if it's on Alpha Centauri. Gifted and talented kids: how do you nurture a curious mind. One should take seriously the danger that hes not the only one deluding himself. The movie gives two examples of experiments which have shown the power of the mind affecting reality. On August 1, 2006 What the Bleep! And quantum mechanics is often used as the explanation for that. Thus, if a scientist repeats an experiment with subatomic particles often enough, the results will closely match the probabilities quantum theory predicts. There's just this little matter of the science being a bit bleep. What The Bleep!? Down The Rabbit Hole | Documentary Heaven [4], Lacking the funding and resources of the typical Hollywood film, the filmmakers relied on "guerrilla marketing" first to get the film into theaters, and then to attract audiences. Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Hidden Dimensions, Rachels Musings Rabbit Holes and Other Oddities, Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Philosophy of Science on Blogginheads.tv, For "The Baby Goes Out With The Bathwater" Crowd - SLUniverse Forums. We asked some of Britain's best scientific brains to give us their verdicts, Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning. Seven Times Planet TV Studios Went Way Too Far: ReportWire.org info@planettvstudios.com nicholas@planettvstudios.com Eric@planettvstudios.com Julie@planettvstudios.com Website YouTube Channel Facebook Twitter Instagram Planet TV Studios LHTV LLC Heisenberg basically says you can't get a really accurate fix on both the position and the momentum of a subatomic particle say an electron at the same time. Monitor journalism changes lives because we open that too-small box that most people think they live in. What The Bleep Do We Know DEBUNKED., page 2 Use these social-bookmarking links to share What the bleep are they on about?. Even skeptics concede that we humans can fall into destructive thought patterns and need to cleanse our vision of what's real. As the movie did, this book compels listeners to ask themselves Gre. Then comes "Carl Sagan Meets Madame Blavatsky." All the weirdness of quantum mechanics gets washed out on the scale that we can experience. Prominent if you go by citations that is. [3], Work was split between Toronto-based Mr. X Inc., Lost Boys Studios in Vancouver, and Atomic Visual Effects in Cape Town, South Africa. He claims that in over 5 hours of interviews he explained to the film makers why their concept of how Quantum Physics works has virtually no support in the scientific community. "What the Bleep" misses opportunities to focus credibly on the fascinating work people like Newberg have been doing, and makes the science-and-faith field seem like quackery. - Dr. [9] In his review, Dave Kehr of The New York Times described the "transition from quantum mechanics to cognitive therapy" as "plausible", but stated also that "the subsequent leapfrom cognitive therapy into large, hazy spiritual beliefsisn't as effectively executed. To date, Dr Emoto has not taken up the challenge. Of Hagelins thousands of citations, how many are from the Ellis/Nanopoulous et al paper mill? or call us at 1-617-450-2300. We're such a shallow people. Photos View All Photos Movie Info Amanda, a divorced photographer, has a fantastic experience when life begins to unravel around her, revealing the cellular,. The question is, how far down the rabbit hole, do you wanna go? What the #$*! Do We Know!? (Film) - TV Tropes [1], In mid-2005, the filmmakers worked with HCI Books to expand on the film's themes in a book titled What the Bleep Do We Know! But that doesn't mean that astrology is true. Magician and skeptic James Randi, famous for debunking performers like Uri Geller, has offered his standard prize of $1 million cash money to Dr Emoto if he can get the same results when doing the water study this way. It is true that quantum mechanics is extremely strange, and on extremely small scales for short times, all sorts of weird things happen. "Contrary to ordinary beliefs, quantum physics is very predictive," Dr. de Gouva continues. It went on to say that "Most laypeople cannot tell where the quantum physics ends and the quantum nonsense begins, and many are susceptible to being misguided," and that "a physics student may be unable to convincingly confront unjustified extrapolations of quantum mechanics," a shortcoming which the authors attribute to the current teaching of quantum mechanics, in which "we tacitly deny the mysteries physics has encountered". (It's all to do with photons of light from your measuring instrument hitting the poor electron and knocking it for six). The comments focus primarily on a single theme: "We create our own reality." Whether or not you buy into its "you are God in the making" philosophy, "What the Bleep Do We Know?" While the movie "What The Bleep" has some flaws from a science point of view, science of this type is so foreign to most people, that they feel they have to "jazz it up" to keep people interested. "I begin the book with a quote from Feynman that says, 'Reality takes precedence over public relations, for nature cannot be fooled,'" he told me. (I haven't). is released on Friday. . "What the Bleep do we Know?! is garbage | Naked Science Forum What the Bleep do we know - Internet Archive What was new? His 73 papers are mostly about supersymmetric GUTs and considered quite respectable, with a total of over 5000 citations, including 641 citations for one of them alone. 16 Quotes From the Movies ideas - Pinterest This is one reason physicists studying a subatomic particle create large numbers of them in particle accelerators. ( ) - What the bleep Do we know We may be able to use quantum communication in ways that we haven't done before. The plot follows the fictional story of a photographer, using documentary-style interviews and computer-animated graphics, as she encounters emotional and existential obstacles in her life and begins to consider the idea that individual and group consciousness can influence the material world. I'm always up for a good New Age flick, even one masquerading as a documentary. Interspersed with the plot were interviews with various supposed scientists with something to say about quantum physics, consciousness, God, etc. He claims the drop was achieved. But the movie gradually moves to quantum 'insights' that lead a woman to toss away her antidepressant medication, to the quantum channeling of Ramtha, the 35,000-year-old Lemurian warrior, and on to even greater nonsense." I remember Hagelin wanting to discuss how quantum field theory could explain how TMers were able to levitate, something about how they did this by changing the position of the pole in the propagator. Publishers Weekly What the Bleep Do We Know!? I mean listen, you have very reputable individuals who believe in validation, as experimental proof. How quantum physicists 'review' the 'Bleep' movie So what better thing to have than something that gives you everything you want? Quantum mechanics, the theoretical framework of contemporary physics, is a probability algorithm. The film has a web-site, and there is a long article in Salon explaining that the whole thing is really the production of a cult based in the Pacific Northwest that believes that a woman named JZ Knight is able to channel a 35,000 year old mystic named Ramtha. The figures are a bit rubbery, but the idea that we're only 'aware' of a fraction of our brain's activity is both correct and a huge relief. Sol. Initially, the film was released in only two theaters: one in Yelm, Washington (the home of the producers, which is also the home of Ramtha), and the other the Bagdad Theater in Portland, Oregon, where it was filmed. Do we know" . What the Bleep Do We Know? Puppymonkeybaby proves Rubio talking point Obama is destroying (commonly referred to by its spoken title What the Bleep Do We Know) is a 2004 pseudoscientific film that supports the idea that consciousness and quantum mechanics are somehow related. What the #$*! Miceal Ledwith What the Bleep Do We Know!? | Bleep 2 - The Prodigal Movie In the documentary segments of the film, interviewees discuss the roots and meaning of Amanda's experiences. 'What the Bleep Do We Know?' : An insult to science and spirituality Particles are fluctuations the rules of physics say it's perfectly fine for them to exist at some time and/or place and to be non-existent at another time and/or place. The movie contains interviews from such leaders in their fields as: Candace. She works as a free-lancer for an agency, where her boss is played by Barry Newman. William Arntz has referred to the film as "WTFDWK" in a message to the film's street team. But it's not true for the universe at large. The narrative follows a fictional photographer, Amanda, through her emotional and existential journey of life. [16], David Albert, a philosopher of physics who appears in the film, has accused the filmmakers of selectively editing his interview to make it appear that he endorses the film's thesis that quantum mechanics is linked with consciousness. . "They take advantage of things we don't know very well or can't test very well, then use it in an unfair way," notes Andr de Gouva, a particle physicist at Northwestern University in Evanston, Ill. The film has been described as an example of quantum mysticism, and has been criticized for both misrepresenting science and containing pseudoscience. Knight's compound outside the town of Yelm has been built over the former horse-breeding grounds: The estate consists of JZ's present home, a white 12,800 square foot French chateau styled 4-bedroom house, her original home (a 1,600 sq. Doesn't the quantum world pervade everything that we see around us? All those things can be attributed to quantum mechanics first of all, because it's so poorly understood by the public, and especially because it's so verifiably weird. http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/faith (accessed: April 20, 2009)A note about Fred Wolf's qualifications: He has a Ph.D in Theoretical Physics from UCLA in 1963, although he has not worked in laboratory endeavours since that time. ft. indoor riding arena once used for horse training which was refurbished and floored . Everyone said that you have to see this movie! So I did. Producing, scripting, and co-directing the film, What the BLEEP went on to become a global phenomenon, with well over 100 million viewers experiencing the BLEEP. The Bleep in a Nutshell: 1. Get ABC Sciences weekly newsletter Science Updates, The 'underground astronaut' in search of ancient bones, Voyager probes still signalling from the edge of the Solar System, Solar eclipses: Everything you need to know, Five ways your smartphone could help save lives, Chinese scientists use satellite to smash quantum entanglement record, Einstein's light bending theory directly observed in distant stars for first time, Third gravitational wave detection puts new spin on black holes. You dont have a Christian Science Monitor have described distinct assertions made as pseudoscience. Q: But isn't everything really connected? "The theory can't predict with precision what will happen, but it knows everything that can happen and it will tell you the probability of all these things happening.". According to an article in Fortean Times by David Hambling, the origins of this story likely involved the voyages of Captain James Cook, not Columbus, and an account related by Robert Hughes which said Cook's ships were "complex and unfamiliar as to defy the natives' understanding". Awash in New Age theorizing, real world science and the intellectually unfathomable notion of quantum mechanics, What the 'Bleep' Do We Know!? Right now they use a key that's based on the products of large prime numbers, and no computer could determine the prime factors in a time shorter than the age of the universe. What the Bleep Do We Know?: Discovering the Endless Possibilities for That's not the case. "But that's two leaps beyond what scientists believe to be true.". If you have questions about your account, please What the (Bleep) Were They Thinking? - Skeptico subscription yet. "I create my own reality, says quantum physics," intones one expert, and the viewer could be lured to accept this as proof. Everyone knows quantum mechanics is weird, so why not use that to justify it? "The protagonist, Amanda, played by Academy Award-Winning actress Marlee Matlin, finds herself in a fantastic Alice in Wonderland experience when her daily, uninspired life literally begins to unravel, revealing the uncertain world of the quantum field hidden behind what we consider to be our normal, waking reality. Also, the movie suggests that the quantum idea of matter embracing all its possible states at once applies to the larger world of people and rocks. What the Bleep Do We Know!? [7], According to Publishers Weekly, the film was one of the sleeper hits of 2004, as "word-of-mouth and strategic marketing kept it in theaters for an entire year." It's certainly not. I think of what Niels Bohr said to Wolfgang Pauli about theories that are "not crazy enough to be true." She does play a large role in the movie and you can read all about her nonsense here. : !? - RuTracker.org Perhaps that is why they couldnt see them. The sub-atomic particles that make up the atoms that make up the rock are there too." So does classical physics. [5] Author Barrie Dolnick adds that "people don't want to learn how to do one thing. We might be able to create quantum computers, for example, that will simultaneously do many different calculations at once, because the quantum world is capable of doing many things at the same time. You can begin to be skeptical that the speaker is somehow trying to use quantum mechanics to argue fundamentally that you can change the world by thinking about it. We hear more and more from JZ Knight, a woman channeling the ancient warrior Ramtha, a chap who (through Knight) incidentally leads the Ramtha School of Enlightenment. "What the Bleep Do We Know," a pseudoscientific docudrama that purports to link quantum mechanics and consciousness, would be a riot if people didn't take it so seriously. kazakore (kazakore) January 14, 2010, 6:30pm #10 has been described as "a kind of New Age answer to The Passion of the Christ and other films that adhere to traditional religious teachings. Do We Know!?) [11], Scientists who have reviewed What the Bleep Do We Know!? Krauss discussed his criteria ln our interview last week. The director, William Arntz, has described What the Bleep as a film for the "metaphysical left". ", Critics offered mixed reviews as seen on the film review website Rotten Tomatoes, where it scored a "Rotten" 34% score with an average score of 4.6/10, based on 77 reviews. Your session to The Christian There's nothing wrong with that. What the Bleep Do We Know!? Next factoid: Crime in Washington, D.C. was reduced 25 percent by prayer--and made believers of the D.C. cops! While the (probabilistic) predictions of quantum mechanics are, as far . bleep blorp!" I implore all of you to ignore Rubio's critics and acknowledge that the senator from Florida is absolutely correct. A: Quantum mechanics is often quoted as the explanation for many things, because it's so weird that people latch onto it as a hope, to explain everything that they would like to believe about the universe. Amanda is a photographer, who seems to be highly skilled but not very successful professionally. Quantum mechanics is a replacement for the phrase "anything goes." What the bleep Do we know ( 1080p) What the Bleep Do We Know by William Arntz, Betsy Chase, Mark Vicente It's more like a collision in the editing room between talking heads, an impenetrable human parable and a hallucinogenic animated cartoon. "Quantum physics calculates only possibilities Who/what chooses among these possibilities to bring the actual event of experience? It sounds reasonable, and familiar. I think its a good idea for people to consider the example of Hagelin: hes completely delusional and has zero common sense, but able to function at a high level in the particle theory community. 5.Miceal Ledwith a clergyman with a rather dubious past (see http://unison.ie/irish_independent/stories.php3?ca=36&si=770458&issue_id=7565) is the one chosen by the film makers to be the theological spokesman. Andrew B Newberg, (MD, Radiologist), in What the Bleep Do We Know? I want to mention another point Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. ), is hooked on prescription pills, and mopes about while her chirpy roommate spatters paint around their apartment. In the letter, the authors write: "the movie illustrates the uncertainty principle with a bouncing basketball being in several places at once. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. If it's true, no one's been able to measure it or see the effects. It was clearly time to check the facts for myself. Im not personally familiar with any of Hagelins work but Im sure theres some good physics in there. With researchers and theoretical scientists leading the way, it takes the reader through the looking glass of quantum physics into a universe that is more bizarre and alive than ever imagined. You can renew your subscription or We do, at subatomic scale, behave quantum mechanically. Our mind has enormous potential, but we only use a small part of it for conscious thought, and we miss a lot of what's going on around us. By clicking 'Send to a friend' you agree ABC Online is not responsible for the content contained in your email message. Some ideas discussed in the film are: In the narrative segments of the film, Marlee Matlin portrays Amanda, a photographer who plays the role of everywoman as she experiences her life from startlingly new and different perspectives. Dr Emoto takes photos of crystals formed in freezing water. Amit Gotswami Do We (K)now!? So thanks to Associate Professor Zdenka Kuncik, Professor Peter Schofield and Professor Max Coltheart for shedding some light on the Bleeping thing. Several books have been written about the film's remarkable grassroots marketing campaign, which led to its unprecedented success. . Suddenly people who were talking about subatomic particles are alluding to alternate universes and cosmic forces, all of which can be harnessed in the interest of making Ms. Matlin's character feel better about her thighs. If you wanted to study the impact of spoken, drawn or written sentiments on the formation of crystals in freezing water, you'd have to do a slightly more rigorous study. The idea that our own perceptions can't be trusted is not new, of course. Mon August 23, 2021: The US Food and Drug Administration on Monday granted full approval to the Pfizer/BioNTech Covid-19 vaccine for people age 16 and older. Joe Dispenza, former Ramtha School of Enlightenment teacher, This page was last edited on 13 February 2023, at 23:23. Hambling says it is likely that both the Hughes account and the story told by Pert were exaggerations of the records left by Captain Cook and the botanist Joseph Banks. extrapolates from quantum physics to answer life's big questions. Mark was born in Johannesburg, South Africa . You may or may not believe that there's an external reality beyond what your brain creates; the topic will be a perennial and fertile source of discussion. Reality is happening in our brain all the time we're receiving it but it's not being integrated." Pingback: Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Hidden Dimensions, Pingback: Rachels Musings Rabbit Holes and Other Oddities, Pingback: Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Philosophy of Science on Blogginheads.tv, Pingback: For "The Baby Goes Out With The Bathwater" Crowd - SLUniverse Forums. I guess it's a sign that quantum physics is entering the mainstream A: Well, yeah, the point is that there have been these new-age desires for lots of things to make the world better: crystals, energy vortices. But she is right about us not seeing things in front of our eyes if we're not looking for them. Mark Vicente Unfortunately, it also completely misunderstands it. Around 650 million people watched the moment on television. 19802023 The Christian Science Monitor. Professor Clive Greated wrote that "thinking on neurology and addiction are covered in some detail but, unfortunately, early references in the film to quantum physics are not followed through, leading to a confused message". Is this a hoax to promote positivity? Hagelin was a grad student at Harvard when I was an undergrad and I met him when we were in the same quantum field theory class. This is the person who teaches the brain science in RSE. Otherwise, the process falls "outside the realm of physical statements and has entered the realm of spiritual belief.". But what quantum mechanics doesn't change about the universe is, if you want to change things, you still have to do something. Blending New Age mysticism and quantum physics, What The Bleep Do We Know?! is god-awful. After a successful DVD launch in March of 2005, Fox . to someone you know: One possible answer: they go to an alternative universe where people are asking the same question: 'where'd they go?'" He announced in 1994 (one year after the study) that violent crime had decreased 18%. That's not always true, but it's often true. Invariably only about half the people tested ever notice a woman in a gorilla suit walking across the middle of the screen during the game. They may applaud the central tenets of the movie, but not its disjointed narrative, clunky acting, bizarre thematic segues, and faux "facts." Having watched this travesty of a movie, any real scientist worth his quarks might be gun-shy about joining the debate. "[15], Bernie Hobbs, a science writer with ABC Science Online, explains why the film is incorrect about quantum physics and reality: "The observer effect of quantum physics isn't about people or reality. When you hear the term "quantum consciousness," you should be suspicious. Short Range Tests of Newtons Inverse-Square Law. This is the first coronavirus vaccine approved by the FDA, and is expected to open the door to more vaccine mandates. That movie started its life as a small documentary about Spirit and Science, but grew in scope (and budget) and became What the BLEEP Do We Know!? you refer to the offspring of hep-ph/9803315. Author, speaker, and award-winning Writer/Director/Producer Mark Vicente was part of the creative team behind the sleeper hit "What The Bleep Do We Know?!". Hagelin might be crazy, but some of those papers are co-written by John Ellis and other respectable people. Some lost their entire life savings. "[20], Journalist John Gorenfeld, writing in Salon, notes that the film's three directors are students of Ramtha's School of Enlightenment, which he says has been described as a cult. [PDF] What the Bleep Do We Know ? | Semantic Scholar Check out this great listen on Audible.com. What The Bleep Do We Know Only the Shaman knows, and we're about 500 years too late to ask him. Answer: Photographer. They're coming into the marketplace hungry for direction, but they don't want some person who claims to have all the answers. Our mind has enormous potential, but we only use a small part of it for conscious thought, and we miss a lot of what's going on around us so, in a leap of creatively edited logic 3. Then we segue to a narrative starring Amanda (Marlee Maitlin), a wedding photographer who's bummed because her slimy husband cheated on her. Hambling says it is likely that both the Hughes account and the story told by Pert were exaggerations of the records left by Captain Cook and the botanist Joseph Banks. Interspersed with the plot were interviews with various supposed scientists with something to say about quantum physics, consciousness, God, etc. The question "What the bleep do we know?" has an unambiguous answer: both surprisingly much and amazingly little. There was some sort of plot involving a woman photographer (played by Marlee Matlin), who wanders around and has anxiety attacks. You see my physics students don't understand it. That is because I don't understand it. !" is a radical departure from convention. 3. what the bleep do we know watch online free, what the bleep do we know trailer, what the bleep do we know movie, what the bleep do we know debunked, what the bleep do . Featuring two (!) Unfortunately, it also completely misunderstands it. based on this subject nature contained, I hold these 2 films in a very high regard. It's used as an excuse to be even weirder. You are free to comment as you wish. 7. improve functionality and performance. A: Absolutely. Categories conflate, confound, connect", "Our power is in our ability to decide - Can you? Amit Goswami (PhD) in What the Bleep Do We Know?. Dr Joe Dispenza and Miceal Ledwith are both long time students and appointed teachers at Ramthas school of enlightenment (RSE). She's averse to churches (she married her husband in one, so they must be bad! Your subscription to "What the Bleep Do We Know?" is a trendy new movie that combines the worst elements of a snooze-worthy PBS documentary, a "change your mind, change your life" self-help book, and a Bugs. What the Bleep Do We Know? | Not Even Wrong - Columbia University As the Amanda plot zooms here and there, a host of dubious evidence is marshaled to convince us that life is all about mind over matter.